The Absence Of Emily by Jack Ritchie, 1981
The magic trick:
Immediately establishing the narrator as suspicious, making the reader wonder what the mystery here is at all
Why is Albert acting so guilty? Is he an unreliable narrator? Or is he really just that cocksure? It’s hard to know. Keep reading. And that’s quite a trick on Ritchie’s part.
Eberly studied me. “Are you ill or something, Albert? Your hands seem to be shaking.”
“Touch of the flu,” I said quickly. “Brings out the jitters in me. What brings you here anyway, Amos?”
“Nothing in particular, Albert. I just happened to be in the neighborhood and thought I’d drop in and see Emily.”
“Damn it, I told you she isn’t here.”
“All right, Albert,” he said soothingly. “Why should I doubt you? If you say she isn’t here, she isn’t here.”
Subscribe to the Short Story Magic Tricks Monthly Newsletter to get the latest short story news, contests and fun.