‘A Dark Brown Dog’ by Stephen Crane

Crane, Stephen 1901

A Dark Brown Dog by Stephen Crane, 1901

The magic trick:

Using a metaphor to comment on a major historical time period with a story about a dog

First things first: I don’t like this story. Not a bit. I don’t do well with animals in peril, nor do I like broad, generalized historical comparisons. Ostensibly, the little brown dog in this story is supposed to represent Black America in the Reconstruction South. Whoa, whoa, whoa – you say – what? I know, I know. But I’m not kidding.

Let me stop here, though, and focus on the positives here. The idea that one can write a story about a boy taking in a stray dog and in fact be commenting on a major event or time period in American history is really quite remarkable. I like that idea a lot; the notion that an author can be telling you one thing but really be talking about something entirely different. That’s art, right?

In “A Little Brown Dog,” the metaphor simply doesn’t work for me. The idea that former slaves, as a people, were naive, innocent, eager to please, kind and good and loving, as the dog is in this story? Well, it’s just stupid. I’d argue that such a generalization, no matter the good intentions, is actually just as racist and ignorant as someone who is on a White-Power trip. The metaphor is a dud, and without it, the story has little else on which to prop itself.

Credit Crane at least for attempting such an ambitiously symbolic tale. I suspect his heart was in the right place. And that’s quite a trick on Crane’s part.

The selection:

The affair was quickly ended. The father of the family, it appears, was in a particularly savage temper that evening, and when he perceived that it would amaze and anger everybody if such a dog were allowed to remain, he decided that it should be so. The child, crying softly, took his friend off to a retired part of the room to hobnob with him, while the father quelled a fierce rebellion of his wife. So it came to pass that the dog was a member of the household.


3 thoughts on “‘A Dark Brown Dog’ by Stephen Crane

  1. When can I read something from someone who is not either a dead white guy or in Norton’s Anthology circa 1990? Also why is this text related to “How To Date A Brown Girl (Black Girl, White Girl, Or Halfie)” Is it because they both use the word brown? Isn’t it kind of racist to compare a brown dog with a brown girl? I’m not sure I like where this blog is heading.

  2. Like any literature , one may draw several interesting conclusions . A dark brown dog , May have been a very literal story , intended to shame cruel and dysfunctional people , to protect the voiceless helpless animals. Which people often considered worthless , unless they were purebred . It may have been meant to help bring awareness to the alcohol abstinence prohibition movement of the early 1900’s and late 19th century . Such as in the murder that occurred in Stephen Crane’s “the Blue Hotel” obviously an alcoholic delirium/hallucination that became violent when the Swede began to get drunk after severely beating the boy . Or how Maggie becomes a girl of the streets after having sex with the bartender , and all the drunken debauchery . I see no black slavery issues – it’s alcoholic threads Crane is exposing to the Public eye . I may be wrong .

    • Those are interesting connections. I think you may be right, actually. I’m totally sure I agree with my own assessment here.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s