Notes From A Lady At A DinnerParty by Bernard Malamud, 1973
The magic trick:
Using one scenario to explore at least two very separate ideas
We start a week of Bernard Malamud stories. Malamud’s work is diverse to say the least. Everything from Old World fables to baseball.
Today’s feature, “Notes From A Lady At A Dinner Party,” is diverse in its ideas and tone – just within itself. It’s funny. It’s sad. It’s stressful. It also accomplishes that age-old short story goal: being about two things at the same time.
There is the question of the would-be rendezvous between Adler and Karla, of course. But there is also the less obvious – and more interesting, I think – question of the student usurping the teacher. This scenario entangles both ideas, leaving the reader with multiple ideas to think about. And that’s quite a trick on Malamud’s part.
The professor, a crisp tall man with a clipped grayish beard, faintly red, and thick gray sideburns, who wore a green blazer with an orange shirt and white bow tie, was lavish in his praise of Adler’s recent work, some slides of which the architect had sent him; and Max once more expressed gratitude for the interest Harris continued to show. He had always been a kind man and influential teacher.
“What are you into now?” Harris asked. After two brandies he had gone to Scotch-and-soda. His large face was flushed and he wiped his watery eyes with a pressed handkerchief. Adler had noticed how often he glanced up at the dining-room door in anticipation of his wife’s reappearance.
“The same project you saw in the transparencies,” Adler said. “How about you?”
“Renovating some slum units for a private low-income housing group. There’s very little money in it. It’s more or less pro bono.”
“I ought to be doing more of that myself.”
Subscribe to the Short Story Magic Tricks Monthly Newsletter to get the latest short story news, contests and fun.