Rose by Mavis Gallant, 1960
The magic trick:
Making the ambiguity of a Christmas memory the story’s main theme
The story shows its hand in the first sentence: Childhood recollected is often hallucination. The rest of the text goes on to demonstrate this point. The childhood recollection in question is a girl’s fuzzy memory of a mysterious family member. Did she meet her? Did she imagine it? I don’t know. Childhood is hallucination. And that’s quite a trick on Gallant’s part.
On the journey home, Germaine and I do not discuss Rose. I suspect Germaine of being an accomplice. She wound the gramophone. But I tell my parents: I say that we saw Rose, that there were biscuits, and a tree.”
“Oh, she wouldn’t.”
But they exchange a look, which I catch. They say I am making it up. “We shall ask Grandmother,” they warn.
Subscribe to the Short Story Magic Tricks Monthly Newsletter to get the latest short story news, contests and fun.