Second-Hand Man by Rita Dove, 1985
The magic trick:
Subverting the original premise with a twist ending
There is something of O. Henry to this one. It’s not quite a twist ending, but things turn out to be not as they first seemed. The twist to the twist? Turns out things not being as they first seemed is not a problem at all. And that’s quite a trick on Dove’s part.
Then she saw James. He’d just come up from Tennessee, working his way up on the riverboats. Folks said his best friend had been lynched down there and he turned his back on the town and said he was never coming back. Well, when she saw this cute little man in a straw hat and a twelve-string guitar under his arm, she got a little flustered. Her girlfriends whispered around to find out who he was, but she acted like she didn’t even see him.
Subscribe to the Short Story Magic Tricks Monthly Newsletter to get the latest short story news, contests and fun.